From 85526567310957f6112d6c4ca862377861384903 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: plasmagoat <david.mikael@proton.me>
Date: Wed, 30 Jul 2025 00:22:33 +0200
Subject: [PATCH 1/2] services...

---
 docs/README.md                              |  10 +-
 docs/current-deployment.md                  |   6 +-
 docs/fleet-overview.md                      |   2 +-
 docs/nodes.md                               |   6 +-
 docs/services.md                            | 452 ++++++++++++------
 hosts/sandbox/default.nix                   |   6 +-
 modules/homelab/lib/features/logging.nix    |  69 +--
 modules/homelab/lib/features/monitoring.nix | 124 +++--
 modules/homelab/lib/features/proxy.nix      |  13 +-
 modules/homelab/services/gatus.nix          |  13 +-
 modules/homelab/services/grafana.nix        |  14 +-
 modules/homelab/services/prometheus.nix     |  47 +-
 pkgs/homelab-docs/readme.nix                |   8 +-
 pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix     | 138 ++++++
 pkgs/homelab-docs/services.nix              | 500 ++++++++++++--------
 15 files changed, 918 insertions(+), 490 deletions(-)
 create mode 100644 pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix

diff --git a/docs/README.md b/docs/README.md
index 17e36a8..9984a6d 100644
--- a/docs/README.md
+++ b/docs/README.md
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ This documentation is automatically generated from your colmena flake configurat
 ## 🚀 Quick Actions
 
 ### View Current Status
-\`\`\`bash
+```bash
 # Service status across fleet (if homelab CLI is available)
 homelab services --global
 
@@ -29,22 +29,22 @@ homelab backups --global
 
 # Overall status
 homelab status
-\`\`\`
+```
 
 ### Update Documentation
-\`\`\`bash
+```bash
 # Regenerate all documentation
 homelab-generate-docs ./docs
 
 # Generate in different directory
 homelab-generate-docs /path/to/output
-\`\`\`
+```
 
 ## 📋 Quick Stats
 
 - **Total Nodes**: 2
 - **Homelab-Enabled Nodes**: 2
-- **Generated**: tir 29 jul 16:57:16 CEST 2025
+- **Generated**: ons 30 jul 00:20:46 CEST 2025
 
 ## 🛠️ Management Tools
 
diff --git a/docs/current-deployment.md b/docs/current-deployment.md
index 2f1541c..c43eccf 100644
--- a/docs/current-deployment.md
+++ b/docs/current-deployment.md
@@ -11,15 +11,15 @@
 |--------|-------|
 | Total Nodes | 2 |
 | Homelab-Enabled Nodes | 2 |
-| Unique Services | 1 |
-| Service Instances | 1 |
+| Unique Services | 4 |
+| Service Instances | 4 |
 
 ## Node Status
 
 | Node | Homelab | Environment | Services | Monitoring | Backups | Proxy |
 |------|---------|-------------|----------|------------|---------|-------|
 | `photos` | ✅ | production | 1 | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
-| `sandbox` | ✅ | production | 0 | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
+| `sandbox` | ✅ | production | 3 | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
 
 ---
 
diff --git a/docs/fleet-overview.md b/docs/fleet-overview.md
index 5982210..866c8bd 100644
--- a/docs/fleet-overview.md
+++ b/docs/fleet-overview.md
@@ -26,7 +26,7 @@
 | Node | Service Count | Services |
 |------|---------------|----------|
 | `photos` | 1 | minio |
-| `sandbox` | 0 |  |
+| `sandbox` | 3 | gatus, grafana, prometheus |
 
 ---
 
diff --git a/docs/nodes.md b/docs/nodes.md
index 87cade4..90a635a 100644
--- a/docs/nodes.md
+++ b/docs/nodes.md
@@ -61,10 +61,10 @@
 
 | Service | Enabled | Port | Description | Tags |
 |---------|---------|------|-------------|------|
-| `gatus` | ❌ | 8080 | Gatus Status Page |  |
-| `grafana` | ❌ | 3000 | Grafana Metrics Dashboard |  |
+| `gatus` | ✅ | 8080 | Gatus Status Page |  |
+| `grafana` | ✅ | 3000 | Grafana Metrics Dashboard |  |
 | `minio` | ❌ | 9000 | minio |  |
-| `prometheus` | ❌ | 9090 | Prometheus Monitoring Server |  |
+| `prometheus` | ✅ | 9090 | Prometheus Monitoring Server |  |
 
 ---
 
diff --git a/docs/services.md b/docs/services.md
index a953b35..7e3571b 100644
--- a/docs/services.md
+++ b/docs/services.md
@@ -1,10 +1,13 @@
 # Service Catalog
 
-> Available services and their configuration options
+> Complete service documentation with core options, feature integrations, and smart defaults
 >
 > Generated on: $(date)
 
-This document catalogs all available homelab services, their configuration options, and integration capabilities.
+This document provides comprehensive documentation for homelab services, organized by:
+- **Core Service Options**: The main service configuration
+- **Feature Integrations**: Available monitoring, logging, and proxy features
+- **Service Defaults**: What this service configures by default for each feature
 
 ## Overview
 
@@ -12,142 +15,252 @@ This document catalogs all available homelab services, their configuration optio
 
 ## Service Integration Matrix
 
-| Service | Monitoring | Logging | Proxy | Auth Default |
-|---------|------------|---------|-------|--------------|
-| `gatus` | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | 🌐 |
-| `grafana` | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | 🌐 |
-| `minio` | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | 🌐 |
-| `prometheus` | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | 🌐 |
+| Service | Core Options | Monitoring | Logging | Proxy | Deployments |
+|---------|--------------|------------|---------|-------|-------------|
+| `gatus` | 11 | 📊 | 📝 | 🔀 | 1 |
+| `grafana` | 3 | 📊 | 📝 | 🔀 | 1 |
+| `minio` | 4 | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ | 1 |
+| `prometheus` | 12 | 📊 | 📝 | 🔀 | 1 |
 
-**Legend:** ✅ = Enabled by default, ❌ = Available but disabled, 🔒 = Auth required, 🌐 = Public access
+**Legend:** 📊📝🔀 = Feature available, ❌ = Feature not available
 
-## Service Reference
+## Service Documentation
 
 ### gatus
 
-**Description:** Gatus Status Page
+**Deployment Status:** 1/2 nodes have this service enabled
 
-**Default Port:** `8080`
+#### Core Service Options
 
-**Current Deployments:** 0 instance(s) on: 
-
-#### Default Integration Status
-
-| Integration | Status | Default Configuration |
-|-------------|--------|----------------------|
-| 📊 Monitoring | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `monitoring.enable = true` |
-| 📝 Logging | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `logging.enable = true` |
-| 🔀 Proxy | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `proxy.enable = true` |
-
-#### Core Configuration
+The main configuration options for gatus:
 
 ```nix
 homelab.services.gatus = {
-  enable = true;
-  port = 8080;
-  description = "Gatus Status Page";
-
-  # Default integrations (adjust as needed)
-  # monitoring.enable = true;  # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # logging.enable = true;     # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # proxy.enable = true;       # ❌ Disabled by default
+  alerting = {};  # Gatus alerting configuration
+  description = Gatus Status Page;  # No description
+  enable = false;  # Whether to enable Gatus Status Page.
+  extraConfig = {};  # Additional Gatus configuration options
+  port = 8080;  # No description
+  storage = {
+  "type": "memory"
+};  # Gatus storage configuration
+  ui.buttons = [
+  {
+    "link": "https://grafana.procopius.dk",
+    "name": "Grafana"
+  },
+  {
+    "link": "https://prometheus.procopius.dk",
+    "name": "Prometheus"
+  }
+];  # Navigation buttons in the Gatus interface
+  ui.header = Homelab Services Status;  # Header text for the Gatus interface
+  ui.link = https://status.procopius.dk;  # Link in the Gatus header
+  ui.title = Homelab Status;  # Title for the Gatus web interface
+  web.address = 0.0.0.0;  # Web interface bind address
 };
 ```
 
-#### Service-Specific Options
+#### Feature Integrations
 
-Available configuration options for gatus:
+##### 📊 Monitoring Integration
+
+Available monitoring options:
 
 ```nix
 homelab.services.gatus = {
   # ... core options above ...
 
-  # Service-specific configuration
-  alerting = {};
-  extraConfig = {};
-  storage = {"type":"memory"};
-  ui = {"buttons":[{"link":"https://grafana.procopius.dk","name":"Grafana"},{"link":"https://prometheus.procopius.dk","name":"Prometheus"}],"header":"Homelab Services Status","link":"https://status.procopius.dk","title":"Homelab Status"};
-  web = {"address":"0.0.0.0"};
+  monitoring.enable = true;  # Enable monitoring for gatus
+  monitoring.extraLabels = {};  # No description
+  monitoring.healthCheck.conditions = [
+  "[STATUS] == 200"
+];  # Health check conditions. Setting conditions enables health checks.
+  monitoring.healthCheck.enable = true;  # No description
+  monitoring.healthCheck.extraChecks = [];  # Additional health checks. Adding checks enables health monitoring.
+  # monitoring.healthCheck.path = <null or string>;  # Health check endpoint path. Setting this enables health checks.
+  monitoring.metrics.enable = false;  # No description
+  monitoring.metrics.extraEndpoints = [];  # Additional metrics endpoints. Adding endpoints enables metrics collection.
+  # monitoring.metrics.path = <null or string>;  # Metrics endpoint path. Setting this enables metrics collection.
 };
 ```
 
+**gatus sets these monitoring defaults:**
+```nix
+  enable = true;
+  extraLabels = {};
+  healthCheck = {"conditions":["[STATUS] == 200"],"enable":true,"extraChecks":[],"path":null};
+  metrics = {"enable":false,"extraEndpoints":[],"path":null};
+```
+
+##### 📝 Logging Integration
+
+Available logging options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.gatus = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  logging.enable = false;  # Enable logging for gatus
+  logging.extraLabels = {};  # No description
+  logging.extraSources = [];  # No description
+  logging.files = [];  # No description
+  # logging.multiline = <null or (submodule)>;  # No description
+  logging.parsing.extractFields = [];  # No description
+  # logging.parsing.regex = <null or string>;  # No description
+};
+```
+
+**gatus sets these logging defaults:**
+```nix
+  enable = false;
+  extraLabels = {};
+  extraSources = [];
+  files = [];
+  multiline = null;
+  parsing = {"extractFields":[],"regex":null};
+```
+
+##### 🔀 Proxy Integration
+
+Available proxy options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.gatus = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  proxy.additionalSubdomains = [];  # No description
+  proxy.enable = true;  # Enable reverse proxy for gatus
+  proxy.enableAuth = false;  # No description
+  proxy.subdomain = gatus;  # No description
+};
+```
+
+**gatus sets these proxy defaults:**
+```nix
+  additionalSubdomains = [];
+  enable = true;
+  enableAuth = false;
+  subdomain = gatus;
+```
+
 ---
 
 ### grafana
 
-**Description:** Grafana Metrics Dashboard
+**Deployment Status:** 1/2 nodes have this service enabled
 
-**Default Port:** `3000`
+#### Core Service Options
 
-**Current Deployments:** 0 instance(s) on: 
-
-#### Default Integration Status
-
-| Integration | Status | Default Configuration |
-|-------------|--------|----------------------|
-| 📊 Monitoring | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `monitoring.enable = true` |
-| 📝 Logging | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `logging.enable = true` |
-| 🔀 Proxy | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `proxy.enable = true` |
-
-#### Core Configuration
+The main configuration options for grafana:
 
 ```nix
 homelab.services.grafana = {
-  enable = true;
-  port = 3000;
-  description = "Grafana Metrics Dashboard";
-
-  # Default integrations (adjust as needed)
-  # monitoring.enable = true;  # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # logging.enable = true;     # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # proxy.enable = true;       # ❌ Disabled by default
+  description = Grafana Metrics Dashboard;  # No description
+  enable = false;  # Whether to enable Grafana Dashboard.
+  port = 3000;  # No description
 };
 ```
 
+#### Feature Integrations
+
+##### 📊 Monitoring Integration
+
+Available monitoring options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.grafana = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  monitoring.enable = true;  # Enable monitoring for grafana
+  monitoring.extraLabels = {};  # No description
+  monitoring.healthCheck.conditions = [
+  "[STATUS] == 200"
+];  # Health check conditions. Setting conditions enables health checks.
+  monitoring.healthCheck.enable = true;  # No description
+  monitoring.healthCheck.extraChecks = [];  # Additional health checks. Adding checks enables health monitoring.
+  # monitoring.healthCheck.path = <null or string>;  # Health check endpoint path. Setting this enables health checks.
+  monitoring.metrics.enable = false;  # No description
+  monitoring.metrics.extraEndpoints = [];  # Additional metrics endpoints. Adding endpoints enables metrics collection.
+  # monitoring.metrics.path = <null or string>;  # Metrics endpoint path. Setting this enables metrics collection.
+};
+```
+
+**grafana sets these monitoring defaults:**
+```nix
+  enable = true;
+  extraLabels = {};
+  healthCheck = {"conditions":["[STATUS] == 200"],"enable":true,"extraChecks":[],"path":null};
+  metrics = {"enable":false,"extraEndpoints":[],"path":null};
+```
+
+##### 📝 Logging Integration
+
+Available logging options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.grafana = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  logging.enable = false;  # Enable logging for grafana
+  logging.extraLabels = {};  # No description
+  logging.extraSources = [];  # No description
+  logging.files = [];  # No description
+  # logging.multiline = <null or (submodule)>;  # No description
+  logging.parsing.extractFields = [];  # No description
+  # logging.parsing.regex = <null or string>;  # No description
+};
+```
+
+**grafana sets these logging defaults:**
+```nix
+  enable = false;
+  extraLabels = {};
+  extraSources = [];
+  files = [];
+  multiline = null;
+  parsing = {"extractFields":[],"regex":null};
+```
+
+##### 🔀 Proxy Integration
+
+Available proxy options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.grafana = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  proxy.additionalSubdomains = [];  # No description
+  proxy.enable = true;  # Enable reverse proxy for grafana
+  proxy.enableAuth = false;  # No description
+  proxy.subdomain = grafana;  # No description
+};
+```
+
+**grafana sets these proxy defaults:**
+```nix
+  additionalSubdomains = [];
+  enable = true;
+  enableAuth = false;
+  subdomain = grafana;
+```
+
 ---
 
 ### minio
 
-**Description:** minio
+**Deployment Status:** 1/2 nodes have this service enabled
 
-**Default Port:** `9000`
+#### Core Service Options
 
-**Current Deployments:** 1 instance(s) on: photos
-
-#### Default Integration Status
-
-| Integration | Status | Default Configuration |
-|-------------|--------|----------------------|
-| 📊 Monitoring | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `monitoring.enable = true` |
-| 📝 Logging | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `logging.enable = true` |
-| 🔀 Proxy | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `proxy.enable = true` |
-
-#### Core Configuration
+The main configuration options for minio:
 
 ```nix
 homelab.services.minio = {
-  enable = true;
-  port = 9000;
-  description = "minio";
-
-  # Default integrations (adjust as needed)
-  # monitoring.enable = true;  # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # logging.enable = true;     # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # proxy.enable = true;       # ❌ Disabled by default
-};
-```
-
-#### Service-Specific Options
-
-Available configuration options for minio:
-
-```nix
-homelab.services.minio = {
-  # ... core options above ...
-
-  # Service-specific configuration
-  openFirewall = true;
-  webPort = 9001;
+  enable = false;  # Whether to enable Minio Object Storage.
+  openFirewall = true;  # Whether to open the ports specified in `port` and `webPort` in the firewall.
+  port = 9000;  # Port of the server.
+  webPort = 9001;  # Port of the web UI (console).
 };
 ```
 
@@ -155,75 +268,132 @@ homelab.services.minio = {
 
 ### prometheus
 
-**Description:** Prometheus Monitoring Server
+**Deployment Status:** 1/2 nodes have this service enabled
 
-**Default Port:** `9090`
+#### Core Service Options
 
-**Current Deployments:** 0 instance(s) on: 
-
-#### Default Integration Status
-
-| Integration | Status | Default Configuration |
-|-------------|--------|----------------------|
-| 📊 Monitoring | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `monitoring.enable = true` |
-| 📝 Logging | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `logging.enable = true` |
-| 🔀 Proxy | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires `proxy.enable = true` |
-
-#### Core Configuration
+The main configuration options for prometheus:
 
 ```nix
 homelab.services.prometheus = {
-  enable = true;
-  port = 9090;
-  description = "Prometheus Monitoring Server";
-
-  # Default integrations (adjust as needed)
-  # monitoring.enable = true;  # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # logging.enable = true;     # ❌ Disabled by default
-  # proxy.enable = true;       # ❌ Disabled by default
+  alertmanager.enable = true;  # Enable integration with Alertmanager
+  alertmanager.url = alertmanager.lab:9093;  # Alertmanager URL
+  description = Prometheus Monitoring Server;  # No description
+  enable = false;  # Whether to enable Prometheus Monitoring Server.
+  extraAlertingRules = [];  # Additional alerting rules
+  extraFlags = [];  # Extra command line flags
+  extraScrapeConfigs = [];  # Additional scrape configurations
+  globalConfig = {
+  "evaluation_interval": "15s",
+  "scrape_interval": "15s"
+};  # Global Prometheus configuration
+  port = 9090;  # No description
+  retention = 15d;  # How long to retain metrics data
+  ruleFiles = [];  # Additional rule files to load
+  systemdServices = [
+  "prometheus.service",
+  "prometheus"
+];  # Systemd services to monitor
 };
 ```
 
-#### Service-Specific Options
+#### Feature Integrations
 
-Available configuration options for prometheus:
+##### 📊 Monitoring Integration
+
+Available monitoring options:
 
 ```nix
 homelab.services.prometheus = {
   # ... core options above ...
 
-  # Service-specific configuration
-  alertmanager = {"enable":true,"url":"alertmanager.lab:9093"};
-  extraAlertingRules = [];
-  extraFlags = [];
-  extraScrapeConfigs = [];
-  globalConfig = {"evaluation_interval":"15s","scrape_interval":"15s"};
-  retention = 15d;
-  ruleFiles = [];
-  systemdServices = ["prometheus.service","prometheus"];
+  monitoring.enable = true;  # Enable monitoring for prometheus
+  monitoring.extraLabels = {};  # No description
+  monitoring.healthCheck.conditions = [
+  "[STATUS] == 200"
+];  # Health check conditions. Setting conditions enables health checks.
+  monitoring.healthCheck.enable = true;  # No description
+  monitoring.healthCheck.extraChecks = [];  # Additional health checks. Adding checks enables health monitoring.
+  # monitoring.healthCheck.path = <null or string>;  # Health check endpoint path. Setting this enables health checks.
+  monitoring.metrics.enable = false;  # No description
+  monitoring.metrics.extraEndpoints = [];  # Additional metrics endpoints. Adding endpoints enables metrics collection.
+  # monitoring.metrics.path = <null or string>;  # Metrics endpoint path. Setting this enables metrics collection.
 };
 ```
 
+**prometheus sets these monitoring defaults:**
+```nix
+  enable = true;
+  extraLabels = {};
+  healthCheck = {"conditions":["[STATUS] == 200"],"enable":true,"extraChecks":[],"path":null};
+  metrics = {"enable":false,"extraEndpoints":[],"path":null};
+```
+
+##### 📝 Logging Integration
+
+Available logging options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.prometheus = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  logging.enable = false;  # Enable logging for prometheus
+  logging.extraLabels = {};  # No description
+  logging.extraSources = [];  # No description
+  logging.files = [];  # No description
+  # logging.multiline = <null or (submodule)>;  # No description
+  logging.parsing.extractFields = [];  # No description
+  # logging.parsing.regex = <null or string>;  # No description
+};
+```
+
+**prometheus sets these logging defaults:**
+```nix
+  enable = false;
+  extraLabels = {};
+  extraSources = [];
+  files = [];
+  multiline = null;
+  parsing = {"extractFields":[],"regex":null};
+```
+
+##### 🔀 Proxy Integration
+
+Available proxy options:
+
+```nix
+homelab.services.prometheus = {
+  # ... core options above ...
+
+  proxy.additionalSubdomains = [];  # No description
+  proxy.enable = true;  # Enable reverse proxy for prometheus
+  proxy.enableAuth = false;  # No description
+  proxy.subdomain = prometheus;  # No description
+};
+```
+
+**prometheus sets these proxy defaults:**
+```nix
+  additionalSubdomains = [];
+  enable = true;
+  enableAuth = false;
+  subdomain = prometheus;
+```
+
 ---
 
-## Integration Summary
+## Feature Reference
 
-### Available Integration Types
+### Integration Features
 
-| Integration | Purpose | Default Behavior | Configuration |
-|-------------|---------|------------------|---------------|
-| **📊 Monitoring** | Prometheus metrics + health checks | Service-dependent | `monitoring.enable = true` |
-| **📝 Logging** | Centralized log collection | Service-dependent | `logging.enable = true` |
-| **🔀 Proxy** | Reverse proxy with SSL + auth | Service-dependent | `proxy.enable = true` |
+Homelab services can integrate with three main features:
 
-### Integration Benefits
+- **📊 Monitoring**: Prometheus metrics and health checks
+- **📝 Logging**: Centralized log collection with Promtail/Loki
+- **🔀 Proxy**: Reverse proxy with SSL and authentication
 
-- **🔄 Automatic Discovery:** Enabled integrations are automatically discovered by fleet-wide services
-- **📊 Unified Monitoring:** All metrics and health checks appear in Prometheus/Grafana
-- **📝 Centralized Logging:** All logs are collected and indexed in Loki
-- **🌐 Consistent Access:** All services get consistent subdomain access with SSL
-- **🎯 Smart Defaults:** Each service comes with sensible default configurations
+Each service can import these features and set service-specific defaults.
 
 ---
 
-*This service catalog is generated from actual service configurations across your homelab fleet.*
+*This documentation is generated from actual NixOS module evaluations.*
diff --git a/hosts/sandbox/default.nix b/hosts/sandbox/default.nix
index 70eb387..ebf4475 100644
--- a/hosts/sandbox/default.nix
+++ b/hosts/sandbox/default.nix
@@ -42,9 +42,9 @@
     };
 
     # services.loki.enable = true;
-    # services.prometheus.enable = true;
-    # services.grafana.enable = true;
-    # services.gatus.enable = true;
+    services.prometheus.enable = true;
+    services.grafana.enable = true;
+    services.gatus.enable = true;
   };
 
   system.stateVersion = "25.05";
diff --git a/modules/homelab/lib/features/logging.nix b/modules/homelab/lib/features/logging.nix
index 010b766..60f2cda 100644
--- a/modules/homelab/lib/features/logging.nix
+++ b/modules/homelab/lib/features/logging.nix
@@ -6,9 +6,18 @@ serviceName: {
 with lib; let
   cfg = config.homelab.services.${serviceName};
   homelabCfg = config.homelab;
+
+  shouldEnableLogging =
+    cfg.logging.files
+    != []
+    || cfg.logging.extraSources != [];
 in {
   options.homelab.services.${serviceName}.logging = {
-    enable = mkEnableOption "logging for ${serviceName}";
+    enable = mkOption {
+      type = types.bool;
+      description = "Enable logging for ${serviceName}";
+      default = shouldEnableLogging;
+    };
 
     files = mkOption {
       type = types.listOf types.str;
@@ -51,37 +60,33 @@ in {
     };
   };
 
-  config = mkIf (cfg.enable && cfg.logging.enable) {
-    homelab.logging.sources =
-      [
-        {
-          name = "${serviceName}-logs";
-          type = "file";
-          files = {
-            paths = cfg.logging.files;
-            multiline = cfg.logging.multiline;
+  config = mkIf cfg.enable {
+    homelab.logging.sources = mkIf cfg.logging.enable (
+      # Only create file source if files are specified
+      (optional (cfg.logging.files != []) {
+        name = "${serviceName}-logs";
+        type = "file";
+        files = {
+          paths = cfg.logging.files;
+          multiline = cfg.logging.multiline;
+        };
+        labels =
+          cfg.logging.extraLabels
+          // {
+            service = serviceName;
+            node = homelabCfg.hostname;
+            environment = homelabCfg.environment;
           };
-          labels =
-            cfg.logging.extraLabels
-            // {
-              service = serviceName;
-              node = homelabCfg.hostname;
-              environment = homelabCfg.environment;
-            };
-          pipelineStages =
-            mkIf (cfg.logging.parsing.regex != null) [
-              {
-                regex.expression = cfg.logging.parsing.regex;
-              }
-            ]
-            ++ [
-              {
-                labels = listToAttrs (map (field: nameValuePair field null) cfg.logging.parsing.extractFields);
-              }
-            ];
-          enabled = true;
-        }
-      ]
-      ++ cfg.logging.extraSources;
+        pipelineStages =
+          (optional (cfg.logging.parsing.regex != null) {
+            regex.expression = cfg.logging.parsing.regex;
+          })
+          ++ (optional (cfg.logging.parsing.extractFields != []) {
+            labels = listToAttrs (map (field: nameValuePair field null) cfg.logging.parsing.extractFields);
+          });
+        enabled = true;
+      })
+      ++ cfg.logging.extraSources
+    );
   };
 }
diff --git a/modules/homelab/lib/features/monitoring.nix b/modules/homelab/lib/features/monitoring.nix
index 90b36f9..f25e3b8 100644
--- a/modules/homelab/lib/features/monitoring.nix
+++ b/modules/homelab/lib/features/monitoring.nix
@@ -6,47 +6,69 @@ serviceName: {
 with lib; let
   cfg = config.homelab.services.${serviceName};
   homelabCfg = config.homelab;
+
+  hasMetricsConfig =
+    cfg.monitoring.metrics.path
+    != null
+    || cfg.monitoring.metrics.extraEndpoints != [];
+
+  hasHealthCheckConfig =
+    cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.path
+    != null
+    || cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.conditions != []
+    || cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.extraChecks != [];
 in {
   # Define the service-specific monitoring options
   options.homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring = {
-    enable = mkEnableOption "monitoring for ${serviceName}";
+    enable = mkOption {
+      type = types.bool;
+      description = "Enable monitoring for ${serviceName}";
+      default = hasMetricsConfig || hasHealthCheckConfig;
+    };
 
     metrics = {
       enable = mkOption {
         type = types.bool;
-        default = true;
+        default = hasMetricsConfig;
       };
 
       path = mkOption {
-        type = types.str;
-        default = "/metrics";
+        type = types.nullOr types.str;
+        default = null;
+        description = "Metrics endpoint path. Setting this enables metrics collection.";
       };
 
       extraEndpoints = mkOption {
         type = types.listOf types.attrs;
         default = [];
+        description = "Additional metrics endpoints. Adding endpoints enables metrics collection.";
       };
     };
 
     healthCheck = {
       enable = mkOption {
         type = types.bool;
-        default = true;
+        default = hasHealthCheckConfig;
       };
 
       path = mkOption {
-        type = types.str;
-        default = "/health";
+        type = types.nullOr types.str;
+        default = null;
+        description = "Health check endpoint path. Setting this enables health checks.";
+        example = "/health";
       };
 
       conditions = mkOption {
         type = types.listOf types.str;
         default = ["[STATUS] == 200"];
+        description = "Health check conditions. Setting conditions enables health checks.";
+        example = ["[STATUS] == 200"];
       };
 
       extraChecks = mkOption {
         type = types.listOf types.attrs;
         default = [];
+        description = "Additional health checks. Adding checks enables health monitoring.";
       };
     };
 
@@ -57,52 +79,50 @@ in {
   };
 
   # Generate the homelab config automatically when service is enabled
-  config = mkIf (cfg.enable && cfg.monitoring.enable) {
-    homelab.monitoring = {
-      metrics =
-        [
-          {
-            name = "${serviceName}-main";
-            host = homelabCfg.hostname;
-            port = cfg.port;
-            path = cfg.monitoring.metrics.path;
-            jobName = serviceName;
-            scrapeInterval = "30s";
-            labels =
-              cfg.monitoring.extraLabels
-              // {
-                service = serviceName;
-                node = homelabCfg.hostname;
-                environment = homelabCfg.environment;
-              };
-          }
-        ]
-        ++ cfg.monitoring.metrics.extraEndpoints;
+  config = mkIf cfg.enable {
+    homelab.monitoring = mkIf cfg.monitoring.enable {
+      metrics = mkIf hasMetricsConfig (
+        (optional (cfg.monitoring.metrics.path != null) {
+          name = "${serviceName}-main";
+          host = homelabCfg.hostname;
+          port = cfg.port;
+          path = cfg.monitoring.metrics.path;
+          jobName = serviceName;
+          scrapeInterval = "30s";
+          labels =
+            cfg.monitoring.extraLabels
+            // {
+              service = serviceName;
+              node = homelabCfg.hostname;
+              environment = homelabCfg.environment;
+            };
+        })
+        ++ cfg.monitoring.metrics.extraEndpoints
+      );
 
-      healthChecks =
-        [
-          {
-            name = "${serviceName}-health";
-            host = homelabCfg.hostname;
-            port = cfg.port;
-            path = cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.path;
-            protocol = "http";
-            method = "GET";
-            interval = "30s";
-            timeout = "10s";
-            conditions = cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.conditions;
-            group = "services";
-            labels =
-              cfg.monitoring.extraLabels
-              // {
-                service = serviceName;
-                node = homelabCfg.hostname;
-                environment = homelabCfg.environment;
-              };
-            enabled = true;
-          }
-        ]
-        ++ cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.extraChecks;
+      healthChecks = mkIf hasHealthCheckConfig (
+        (optional (cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.path != null) {
+          name = "${serviceName}-health";
+          host = homelabCfg.hostname;
+          port = cfg.port;
+          path = cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.path;
+          protocol = "http";
+          method = "GET";
+          interval = "30s";
+          timeout = "10s";
+          conditions = cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.conditions;
+          group = "services";
+          labels =
+            cfg.monitoring.extraLabels
+            // {
+              service = serviceName;
+              node = homelabCfg.hostname;
+              environment = homelabCfg.environment;
+            };
+          enabled = true;
+        })
+        ++ cfg.monitoring.healthCheck.extraChecks
+      );
     };
   };
 }
diff --git a/modules/homelab/lib/features/proxy.nix b/modules/homelab/lib/features/proxy.nix
index 2658c7a..595f4c0 100644
--- a/modules/homelab/lib/features/proxy.nix
+++ b/modules/homelab/lib/features/proxy.nix
@@ -8,7 +8,11 @@ with lib; let
   homelabCfg = config.homelab;
 in {
   options.homelab.services.${serviceName}.proxy = {
-    enable = mkEnableOption "reverse proxy for ${serviceName}";
+    enable = mkOption {
+      type = types.bool;
+      description = "Enable reverse proxy for ${serviceName}";
+      default = true;
+    };
 
     subdomain = mkOption {
       type = types.str;
@@ -39,8 +43,8 @@ in {
     };
   };
 
-  config = mkIf (cfg.enable && cfg.proxy.enable) {
-    homelab.reverseProxy.entries =
+  config = mkIf cfg.enable {
+    homelab.reverseProxy.entries = mkIf cfg.proxy.enable (
       [
         {
           subdomain = cfg.proxy.subdomain;
@@ -59,6 +63,7 @@ in {
         enableAuth = sub.enableAuth;
         enableSSL = true;
       })
-      cfg.proxy.additionalSubdomains;
+      cfg.proxy.additionalSubdomains
+    );
   };
 }
diff --git a/modules/homelab/services/gatus.nix b/modules/homelab/services/gatus.nix
index da907c4..3bdd610 100644
--- a/modules/homelab/services/gatus.nix
+++ b/modules/homelab/services/gatus.nix
@@ -219,8 +219,7 @@ in {
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring.enable = mkDefault true;
     }
 
-    # Smart defaults for Gatus
-    (mkIf cfg.monitoring.enable {
+    {
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring = mkDefault {
         metrics = {
           path = "/metrics";
@@ -240,9 +239,9 @@ in {
           tier = "monitoring";
         };
       };
-    })
+    }
 
-    (mkIf cfg.logging.enable {
+    {
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.logging = mkDefault {
         files = ["/var/log/gatus/gatus.log"];
         parsing = {
@@ -255,13 +254,13 @@ in {
           application = "gatus";
         };
       };
-    })
+    }
 
-    (mkIf cfg.proxy.enable {
+    {
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.proxy = mkDefault {
         subdomain = "status";
         enableAuth = false; # Status page should be public
       };
-    })
+    }
   ]);
 }
diff --git a/modules/homelab/services/grafana.nix b/modules/homelab/services/grafana.nix
index 5f5aad9..2663cc9 100644
--- a/modules/homelab/services/grafana.nix
+++ b/modules/homelab/services/grafana.nix
@@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ in {
     }
 
     # Smart defaults for Grafana
-    (mkIf cfg.logging.enable {
+    {
       # Grafana-specific log setup
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.logging = mkDefault {
         files = ["/var/log/grafana/grafana.log"];
@@ -59,9 +59,8 @@ in {
           component = "dashboard";
         };
       };
-    })
-
-    (mkIf cfg.monitoring.enable {
+    }
+    {
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring = mkDefault {
         metrics.path = "/metrics";
         healthCheck = {
@@ -73,14 +72,13 @@ in {
           tier = "monitoring";
         };
       };
-    })
-
-    (mkIf cfg.proxy.enable {
+    }
+    {
       # Grafana needs auth by default (admin interface)
       homelab.services.${serviceName}.proxy = mkDefault {
         subdomain = "grafana";
         # enableAuth = true;
       };
-    })
+    }
   ]);
 }
diff --git a/modules/homelab/services/prometheus.nix b/modules/homelab/services/prometheus.nix
index b3f398b..dabc086 100644
--- a/modules/homelab/services/prometheus.nix
+++ b/modules/homelab/services/prometheus.nix
@@ -168,7 +168,6 @@ in {
 
   # Service configuration with smart defaults
   config = mkIf cfg.enable (mkMerge [
-    # Core Prometheus service
     {
       services.prometheus = {
         enable = true;
@@ -203,39 +202,21 @@ in {
       };
 
       networking.firewall.allowedTCPPorts = [cfg.port];
-
-      homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring.enable = mkDefault true;
     }
+    {
+      homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring = {
+        metrics.path = "/metrics";
+        healthCheck.path = "/-/healthy"; # ✅ Enables health checks
+        healthCheck.conditions = ["[STATUS] == 200" "[RESPONSE_TIME] < 1000"];
 
-    # Smart defaults for Prometheus
-    (mkIf cfg.monitoring.enable {
-      homelab.services.${serviceName}.monitoring = mkDefault {
-        metrics = {
-          path = "/metrics";
-          extraEndpoints = [];
-        };
-        healthCheck = {
-          path = "/-/healthy";
-          conditions = ["[STATUS] == 200" "[RESPONSE_TIME] < 1000"];
-          extraChecks = [
-            {
-              name = "prometheus-ready";
-              port = cfg.port;
-              path = "/-/ready";
-              conditions = ["[STATUS] == 200"];
-              group = "monitoring";
-            }
-          ];
-        };
         extraLabels = {
           component = "monitoring-server";
           tier = "monitoring";
         };
       };
-    })
-
-    (mkIf cfg.logging.enable {
-      homelab.services.${serviceName}.logging = mkDefault {
+    }
+    {
+      homelab.services.${serviceName}.logging = {
         files = ["/var/log/prometheus/prometheus.log"];
         parsing = {
           # Prometheus log format: ts=2024-01-01T12:00:00.000Z caller=main.go:123 level=info msg="message"
@@ -247,13 +228,11 @@ in {
           application = "prometheus";
         };
       };
-    })
-
-    (mkIf cfg.proxy.enable {
-      homelab.services.${serviceName}.proxy = mkDefault {
-        subdomain = "prometheus";
-        enableAuth = true; # Admin interface needs protection
+    }
+    {
+      homelab.services.${serviceName}.proxy = {
+        enableAuth = true;
       };
-    })
+    }
   ]);
 }
diff --git a/pkgs/homelab-docs/readme.nix b/pkgs/homelab-docs/readme.nix
index 7a0891f..505d465 100644
--- a/pkgs/homelab-docs/readme.nix
+++ b/pkgs/homelab-docs/readme.nix
@@ -30,7 +30,7 @@ writeShellScriptBin "homelab-docs-readme" ''
   ## 🚀 Quick Actions
 
   ### View Current Status
-  \`\`\`bash
+  ```bash
   # Service status across fleet (if homelab CLI is available)
   homelab services --global
 
@@ -39,16 +39,16 @@ writeShellScriptBin "homelab-docs-readme" ''
 
   # Overall status
   homelab status
-  \`\`\`
+  ```
 
   ### Update Documentation
-  \`\`\`bash
+  ```bash
   # Regenerate all documentation
   homelab-generate-docs ./docs
 
   # Generate in different directory
   homelab-generate-docs /path/to/output
-  \`\`\`
+  ```
 
   ## 📋 Quick Stats
 
diff --git a/pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix b/pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..dba33df
--- /dev/null
+++ b/pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix
@@ -0,0 +1,138 @@
+# service-evaluator.nix - Pure Nix evaluation logic for service documentation
+{
+  nodes,
+  pkgs,
+  lib,
+  ...
+}: let
+  # Helper to recursively extract option information
+  extractOptions = path: options: let
+    pathStr = lib.concatStringsSep "." path;
+  in
+    lib.flatten (lib.mapAttrsToList (
+        name: value: let
+          currentPath = path ++ [name];
+          currentPathStr = lib.concatStringsSep "." currentPath;
+        in
+          if (value._type or null) == "option"
+          then
+            # This is an actual NixOS option
+            [
+              {
+                name = currentPathStr;
+                type = value.type.description or (builtins.typeOf (value.default or null));
+                default = value.default or null;
+                defaultText =
+                  if value ? defaultText
+                  then value.defaultText.text or null
+                  else null;
+                description = value.description or "No description available";
+                example = value.example or null;
+                readOnly = value.readOnly or false;
+              }
+            ]
+          else if lib.isAttrs value && !(lib.hasAttr "_type" value)
+          then
+            # This is a nested attribute set, recurse
+            extractOptions currentPath value
+          else
+            # Skip other types
+            []
+      )
+      options);
+
+  # Get service options from the first node (they should be the same across nodes)
+  firstNode = lib.head (lib.attrValues nodes);
+  homelabServices = firstNode.options.homelab.services or {};
+
+  # Extract all services and their options
+  serviceDefinitions =
+    lib.mapAttrs (serviceName: serviceOptions: {
+      inherit serviceName;
+      options = extractOptions [] serviceOptions;
+      features = let
+        optionNames = map (opt: opt.name) (extractOptions [] serviceOptions);
+      in {
+        hasMonitoring = lib.any (name: lib.hasPrefix "monitoring" name) optionNames;
+        hasLogging = lib.any (name: lib.hasPrefix "logging" name) optionNames;
+        hasProxy = lib.any (name: lib.hasPrefix "proxy" name) optionNames;
+      };
+    })
+    homelabServices;
+
+  # Also get all services that exist in actual configurations (for deployment info)
+  allConfiguredServices = lib.unique (lib.flatten (lib.mapAttrsToList (
+      nodeName: node:
+        if (node.config.homelab.enable or false)
+        then lib.attrNames (node.config.homelab.services or {})
+        else []
+    )
+    nodes));
+
+  # For each service, get deployment info
+  serviceDeployments = lib.listToAttrs (map (serviceName: {
+      name = serviceName;
+      value =
+        lib.foldl (
+          acc: nodeName: let
+            node = nodes.${nodeName};
+            serviceConfig = node.config.homelab.services.${serviceName} or null;
+            isEnabled =
+              if serviceConfig != null
+              then serviceConfig.enable or false
+              else false;
+          in
+            if serviceConfig != null
+            then
+              acc
+              // {
+                totalNodes = acc.totalNodes + 1;
+                enabledNodes =
+                  acc.enabledNodes
+                  + (
+                    if isEnabled
+                    then 1
+                    else 0
+                  );
+                nodeNames = acc.nodeNames ++ [nodeName];
+                enabledNodeNames =
+                  acc.enabledNodeNames
+                  ++ (
+                    if isEnabled
+                    then [nodeName]
+                    else []
+                  );
+              }
+            else acc
+        ) {
+          totalNodes = 0;
+          enabledNodes = 0;
+          nodeNames = [];
+          enabledNodeNames = [];
+        } (lib.attrNames nodes);
+    })
+    allConfiguredServices);
+
+  # Combine service definitions with deployment info
+  servicesWithDeployment =
+    lib.mapAttrs (
+      serviceName: serviceData:
+        serviceData
+        // {
+          deployment =
+            serviceDeployments.${
+              serviceName
+            } or {
+              totalNodes = 0;
+              enabledNodes = 0;
+              nodeNames = [];
+              enabledNodeNames = [];
+            };
+        }
+    )
+    serviceDefinitions;
+in {
+  services = servicesWithDeployment;
+  totalServices = lib.length (lib.attrNames servicesWithDeployment);
+  allConfiguredServices = allConfiguredServices;
+}
diff --git a/pkgs/homelab-docs/services.nix b/pkgs/homelab-docs/services.nix
index 7e6c8a3..808c746 100644
--- a/pkgs/homelab-docs/services.nix
+++ b/pkgs/homelab-docs/services.nix
@@ -1,4 +1,3 @@
-# homelab-docs-services.nix - Service documentation generator CLI
 {
   writeShellScriptBin,
   jq,
@@ -10,261 +9,376 @@ writeShellScriptBin "homelab-docs-services" ''
   cat << 'EOF'
   # Service Catalog
 
-  > Available services and their configuration options
+  > Complete service documentation with core options, feature integrations, and smart defaults
   >
   > Generated on: $(date)
 
-  This document catalogs all available homelab services, their configuration options, and integration capabilities.
+  This document provides comprehensive documentation for homelab services, organized by:
+  - **Core Service Options**: The main service configuration
+  - **Feature Integrations**: Available monitoring, logging, and proxy features
+  - **Service Defaults**: What this service configures by default for each feature
 
   EOF
 
-  # Get all services and their configurations
-  services_catalog=$(colmena eval -E '{ nodes, pkgs, lib, ... }:
+  # Extract comprehensive service information
+  echo "Extracting service information..." >&2
+  services_catalog=$(colmena eval -E '
+    { nodes, pkgs, lib, ... }:
     let
-      # Collect all services from all nodes to build a complete catalog
-      allServiceConfigs = lib.flatten (lib.mapAttrsToList (nodeName: node:
-        if (node.config.homelab.enable or false) then
-          lib.mapAttrsToList (serviceName: service: {
-            inherit serviceName;
-            config = {
-              # Core service options
-              enable = service.enable or false;
-              port = service.port or null;
-              description = service.description or serviceName;
-              tags = service.tags or [];
+      # Helper to extract option information
+      extractOptions = path: options:
+        lib.flatten (lib.mapAttrsToList (name: value:
+          let
+            currentPath = path ++ [name];
+            pathStr = lib.concatStringsSep "." currentPath;
+          in
+          if (value._type or null) == "option" then
+            [{
+              name = pathStr;
+              type = value.type.description or "unknown";
+              default = value.default or null;
+              defaultText = if value ? defaultText then value.defaultText.text or null else null;
+              description = value.description or "No description";
+              readOnly = value.readOnly or false;
+            }]
+          else if lib.isAttrs value && !(lib.hasAttr "_type" value) then
+            extractOptions currentPath value
+          else []
+        ) options);
 
-              # Integration options
-              monitoring = {
-                enabled = service.monitoring.enable or false;
-                metricsPath = service.monitoring.metrics.path or "/metrics";
-                healthPath = service.monitoring.healthCheck.path or "/health";
-                extraLabels = service.monitoring.extraLabels or {};
-              };
+      # Get first node for option definitions
+      firstNode = lib.head (lib.attrValues nodes);
+      homelabServices = firstNode.options.homelab.services or {};
 
-              logging = {
-                enabled = service.logging.enable or false;
-                files = service.logging.files or [];
-                extraLabels = service.logging.extraLabels or {};
-              };
-
-              proxy = {
-                enabled = service.proxy.enable or false;
-                subdomain = service.proxy.subdomain or serviceName;
-                enableAuth = service.proxy.enableAuth or false;
-              };
-
-              # Service-specific options (everything else)
-              serviceSpecific = removeAttrs service [
-                "enable" "port" "description" "tags"
-                "monitoring" "logging" "proxy"
-              ];
-            };
-            deployedOn = nodeName;
-          }) (node.config.homelab.services or {})
-        else []
-      ) nodes);
-
-      # Group by service name and merge configurations
-      serviceGroups = lib.groupBy (svc: svc.serviceName) allServiceConfigs;
-
-      # Get unique services with merged configuration examples
-      uniqueServices = lib.mapAttrs (serviceName: instances:
+      # Process each service
+      serviceInfo = lib.mapAttrs (serviceName: serviceOptions:
         let
-          # Take the first enabled instance as the canonical example
-          enabledInstances = lib.filter (inst: inst.config.enable) instances;
-          canonicalConfig = if enabledInstances != [] then (lib.head enabledInstances).config else (lib.head instances).config;
+          allOptions = extractOptions [] serviceOptions;
+
+          # Separate core options from feature options
+          coreOptions = lib.filter (opt:
+            !(lib.hasPrefix "monitoring." opt.name) &&
+            !(lib.hasPrefix "logging." opt.name) &&
+            !(lib.hasPrefix "proxy." opt.name)
+          ) allOptions;
+
+          monitoringOptions = lib.filter (opt: lib.hasPrefix "monitoring." opt.name) allOptions;
+          loggingOptions = lib.filter (opt: lib.hasPrefix "logging." opt.name) allOptions;
+          proxyOptions = lib.filter (opt: lib.hasPrefix "proxy." opt.name) allOptions;
+
+          # Get actual service configuration to see what defaults are set
+          serviceConfigs = lib.mapAttrs (nodeName: node:
+            let
+              serviceConfig = node.config.homelab.services.''${serviceName} or null;
+            in
+            if serviceConfig != null then {
+              exists = true;
+              enabled = serviceConfig.enable or false;
+              # Extract the computed configuration values
+              monitoring = serviceConfig.monitoring or {};
+              logging = serviceConfig.logging or {};
+              proxy = serviceConfig.proxy or {};
+              # Get other core options
+              coreConfig = removeAttrs serviceConfig ["monitoring" "logging" "proxy"];
+            } else {
+              exists = false;
+            }
+          ) nodes;
+
+          # Find a node where this service exists to get default values
+          nodeWithService = lib.findFirst (nodeName: serviceConfigs.''${nodeName}.exists) null (lib.attrNames nodes);
+          exampleConfig = if nodeWithService != null then serviceConfigs.''${nodeWithService} else null;
+
         in {
           inherit serviceName;
-          config = canonicalConfig;
-          deploymentCount = lib.length (lib.filter (inst: inst.config.enable) instances);
-          deployedOn = lib.unique (map (inst: inst.deployedOn or "unknown") enabledInstances);
+          coreOptions = coreOptions;
+          features = {
+            monitoring = {
+              available = monitoringOptions != [];
+              options = monitoringOptions;
+              defaults = if exampleConfig != null then exampleConfig.monitoring else {};
+            };
+            logging = {
+              available = loggingOptions != [];
+              options = loggingOptions;
+              defaults = if exampleConfig != null then exampleConfig.logging else {};
+            };
+            proxy = {
+              available = proxyOptions != [];
+              options = proxyOptions;
+              defaults = if exampleConfig != null then exampleConfig.proxy else {};
+            };
+          };
+          deployment = {
+            totalNodes = lib.length (lib.filter (cfg: cfg.exists) (lib.attrValues serviceConfigs));
+            enabledNodes = lib.length (lib.filter (cfg: cfg.exists && cfg.enabled) (lib.attrValues serviceConfigs));
+          };
         }
-      ) serviceGroups;
+      ) homelabServices;
 
     in {
-      services = uniqueServices;
-      totalUniqueServices = lib.length (lib.attrNames uniqueServices);
-    }')
+      services = serviceInfo;
+      totalServices = lib.length (lib.attrNames serviceInfo);
+    }
+  ')
 
-  total_services=$(echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.totalUniqueServices')
+  total_services=$(echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.totalServices')
 
   echo "## Overview"
   echo
   echo "**Total Available Services:** $total_services"
   echo
 
-  # Create a summary table of services and their default integrations
+  # Service matrix
   echo "## Service Integration Matrix"
   echo
-  echo "| Service | Monitoring | Logging | Proxy | Auth Default |"
-  echo "|---------|------------|---------|-------|--------------|"
+  echo "| Service | Core Options | Monitoring | Logging | Proxy | Deployments |"
+  echo "|---------|--------------|------------|---------|-------|-------------|"
 
-  echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.services | to_entries[] | .key' | sort | while read -r service; do
+  echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.services | keys[]' | sort | while read -r service; do
       service_data=$(echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r ".services[\"$service\"]")
 
-      monitoring_enabled=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.monitoring.enabled')
-      logging_enabled=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.logging.enabled')
-      proxy_enabled=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.proxy.enabled')
-      auth_default=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.proxy.enableAuth')
+      core_count=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.coreOptions | length')
+      has_monitoring=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.monitoring.available')
+      has_logging=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.logging.available')
+      has_proxy=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.proxy.available')
+      enabled_deployments=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.deployment.enabledNodes')
 
-      monitoring_icon=$(if [[ "$monitoring_enabled" == "true" ]]; then echo "✅"; else echo "❌"; fi)
-      logging_icon=$(if [[ "$logging_enabled" == "true" ]]; then echo "✅"; else echo "❌"; fi)
-      proxy_icon=$(if [[ "$proxy_enabled" == "true" ]]; then echo "✅"; else echo "❌"; fi)
-      auth_icon=$(if [[ "$auth_default" == "true" ]]; then echo "🔒"; else echo "🌐"; fi)
+      monitoring_icon=$(if [[ "$has_monitoring" == "true" ]]; then echo "📊"; else echo "❌"; fi)
+      logging_icon=$(if [[ "$has_logging" == "true" ]]; then echo "📝"; else echo "❌"; fi)
+      proxy_icon=$(if [[ "$has_proxy" == "true" ]]; then echo "🔀"; else echo "❌"; fi)
 
-      echo "| \`$service\` | $monitoring_icon | $logging_icon | $proxy_icon | $auth_icon |"
+      echo "| \`$service\` | $core_count | $monitoring_icon | $logging_icon | $proxy_icon | $enabled_deployments |"
   done
 
   echo
-  echo "**Legend:** ✅ = Enabled by default, ❌ = Available but disabled, 🔒 = Auth required, 🌐 = Public access"
+  echo "**Legend:** 📊📝🔀 = Feature available, ❌ = Feature not available"
   echo
 
-  echo "## Service Reference"
+  echo "## Service Documentation"
   echo
 
   # Process each service
-  echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.services | to_entries[] | .key' | sort | while read -r service; do
+  echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.services | keys[]' | sort | while read -r service; do
       echo "### $service"
       echo
 
-      # Get service details
       service_data=$(echo "$services_catalog" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r ".services[\"$service\"]")
+      enabled_deployments=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.deployment.enabledNodes')
+      total_deployments=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.deployment.totalNodes')
 
-      description=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.description // "No description available"')
-      port=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.port // "N/A"')
-      tags=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.tags | join(", ")')
-      deployment_count=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.deploymentCount')
-      deployed_on=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.deployedOn | join(", ")')
-
-      echo "**Description:** $description"
-      echo
-      echo "**Default Port:** \`$port\`"
-      echo
-      if [[ -n "$tags" && "$tags" != "" ]]; then
-          echo "**Tags:** $tags"
-          echo
-      fi
-      echo "**Current Deployments:** $deployment_count instance(s) on: $deployed_on"
-      echo
-
-      # Integration Status Overview
-      monitoring_enabled=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.monitoring.enabled')
-      logging_enabled=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.logging.enabled')
-      proxy_enabled=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.proxy.enabled')
-
-      echo "#### Default Integration Status"
-      echo
-      echo "| Integration | Status | Default Configuration |"
-      echo "|-------------|--------|----------------------|"
-
-      # Monitoring status
-      if [[ "$monitoring_enabled" == "true" ]]; then
-          metrics_path=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.monitoring.metricsPath')
-          health_path=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.monitoring.healthPath')
-          echo "| 📊 Monitoring | ✅ **Enabled** | Metrics: \`$metrics_path\`, Health: \`$health_path\` |"
+      if [[ "$total_deployments" -gt 0 ]]; then
+          echo "**Deployment Status:** $enabled_deployments/$total_deployments nodes have this service enabled"
       else
-          echo "| 📊 Monitoring | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires \`monitoring.enable = true\` |"
+          echo "**Deployment Status:** Available but not configured"
       fi
-
-      # Logging status
-      if [[ "$logging_enabled" == "true" ]]; then
-          log_files=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.logging.files | length')
-          if [[ "$log_files" -gt 0 ]]; then
-              echo "| 📝 Logging | ✅ **Enabled** | Collecting $log_files log file(s) |"
-          else
-              echo "| 📝 Logging | ✅ **Enabled** | Auto-configured log collection |"
-          fi
-      else
-          echo "| 📝 Logging | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires \`logging.enable = true\` |"
-      fi
-
-      # Proxy status
-      if [[ "$proxy_enabled" == "true" ]]; then
-          subdomain=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.proxy.subdomain')
-          enable_auth=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.proxy.enableAuth')
-          auth_status=$(if [[ "$enable_auth" == "true" ]]; then echo "🔒 Auth required"; else echo "🌐 Public access"; fi)
-          echo "| 🔀 Proxy | ✅ **Enabled** | Subdomain: \`$subdomain\`, $auth_status |"
-      else
-          echo "| 🔀 Proxy | ❌ Disabled | Available but requires \`proxy.enable = true\` |"
-      fi
-
       echo
 
-      # Core Configuration
-      echo "#### Core Configuration"
+      # Core Service Configuration
+      echo "#### Core Service Options"
       echo
-      echo "\`\`\`nix"
+      echo "The main configuration options for $service:"
+      echo
+      echo '```nix'
       echo "homelab.services.$service = {"
-      echo "  enable = true;"
-      if [[ "$port" != "N/A" ]]; then
-          echo "  port = $port;"
-      fi
-      echo "  description = \"$description\";"
-      if [[ -n "$tags" && "$tags" != "" ]]; then
-          echo "  tags = [ $(echo "$tags" | sed 's/, /" "/g' | sed 's/^/"/; s/$/"/') ];"
-      fi
-      echo
-      echo "  # Default integrations (adjust as needed)"
-      if [[ "$monitoring_enabled" == "true" ]]; then
-          echo "  monitoring.enable = true;  # ✅ Enabled by default"
-      else
-          echo "  # monitoring.enable = true;  # ❌ Disabled by default"
-      fi
-      if [[ "$logging_enabled" == "true" ]]; then
-          echo "  logging.enable = true;     # ✅ Enabled by default"
-      else
-          echo "  # logging.enable = true;     # ❌ Disabled by default"
-      fi
-      if [[ "$proxy_enabled" == "true" ]]; then
-          echo "  proxy.enable = true;       # ✅ Enabled by default"
-      else
-          echo "  # proxy.enable = true;       # ❌ Disabled by default"
-      fi
+
+      echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.coreOptions[] | @base64' | while IFS= read -r option_b64; do
+          option=$(echo "$option_b64" | base64 -d)
+
+          name=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.name')
+          type=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.type')
+          default_val=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.default')
+          description=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.description')
+          read_only=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.readOnly')
+
+          if [[ "$read_only" == "true" ]]; then
+              continue
+          fi
+
+          clean_description=$(echo "$description" | sed 's/"/\\"/g' | tr -d $'\n\r')
+
+          if [[ "$default_val" == "null" ]]; then
+              echo "  # $name = <$type>;  # $clean_description"
+          else
+              echo "  $name = $default_val;  # $clean_description"
+          fi
+      done
+
       echo "};"
-      echo "\`\`\`"
+      echo '```'
       echo
 
-      # Service-specific options
-      service_specific=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.config.serviceSpecific')
-      if [[ "$service_specific" != "{}" && "$service_specific" != "null" ]]; then
-          echo "#### Service-Specific Options"
-          echo
-          echo "Available configuration options for $service:"
-          echo
-          echo "\`\`\`nix"
-          echo "homelab.services.$service = {"
-          echo "  # ... core options above ..."
-          echo
-          echo "  # Service-specific configuration"
-          echo "$service_specific" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r 'to_entries[] | "  \(.key) = \(.value | tostring);"'
-          echo "};"
-          echo "\`\`\`"
+      # Feature Integrations
+      has_monitoring=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.monitoring.available')
+      has_logging=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.logging.available')
+      has_proxy=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.proxy.available')
+
+      if [[ "$has_monitoring" == "true" || "$has_logging" == "true" || "$has_proxy" == "true" ]]; then
+          echo "#### Feature Integrations"
           echo
+
+          # Monitoring Feature
+          if [[ "$has_monitoring" == "true" ]]; then
+              echo "##### 📊 Monitoring Integration"
+              echo
+              echo "Available monitoring options:"
+              echo
+              echo '```nix'
+              echo "homelab.services.$service = {"
+              echo "  # ... core options above ..."
+              echo
+
+              echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.monitoring.options[] | @base64' | while IFS= read -r option_b64; do
+                  option=$(echo "$option_b64" | base64 -d)
+
+                  name=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.name')
+                  type=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.type')
+                  default_val=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.default')
+                  description=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.description')
+                  read_only=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.readOnly')
+
+                  if [[ "$read_only" == "true" ]]; then
+                      continue
+                  fi
+
+                  clean_description=$(echo "$description" | sed 's/"/\\"/g' | tr -d $'\n\r')
+
+                  if [[ "$default_val" == "null" ]]; then
+                      echo "  # $name = <$type>;  # $clean_description"
+                  else
+                      echo "  $name = $default_val;  # $clean_description"
+                  fi
+              done
+
+              echo "};"
+              echo '```'
+
+              # Show service-specific monitoring defaults
+              monitoring_defaults=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.monitoring.defaults')
+              if [[ "$monitoring_defaults" != "{}" && "$monitoring_defaults" != "null" ]]; then
+                  echo
+                  echo "**$service sets these monitoring defaults:**"
+                  echo '```nix'
+                  echo "$monitoring_defaults" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r 'to_entries[] | "  \(.key) = \(.value);"'
+                  echo '```'
+              fi
+              echo
+          fi
+
+          # Logging Feature
+          if [[ "$has_logging" == "true" ]]; then
+              echo "##### 📝 Logging Integration"
+              echo
+              echo "Available logging options:"
+              echo
+              echo '```nix'
+              echo "homelab.services.$service = {"
+              echo "  # ... core options above ..."
+              echo
+
+              echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.logging.options[] | @base64' | while IFS= read -r option_b64; do
+                  option=$(echo "$option_b64" | base64 -d)
+
+                  name=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.name')
+                  type=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.type')
+                  default_val=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.default')
+                  description=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.description')
+                  read_only=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.readOnly')
+
+                  if [[ "$read_only" == "true" ]]; then
+                      continue
+                  fi
+
+                  clean_description=$(echo "$description" | sed 's/"/\\"/g' | tr -d $'\n\r')
+
+                  if [[ "$default_val" == "null" ]]; then
+                      echo "  # $name = <$type>;  # $clean_description"
+                  else
+                      echo "  $name = $default_val;  # $clean_description"
+                  fi
+              done
+
+              echo "};"
+              echo '```'
+
+              # Show service-specific logging defaults
+              logging_defaults=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.logging.defaults')
+              if [[ "$logging_defaults" != "{}" && "$logging_defaults" != "null" ]]; then
+                  echo
+                  echo "**$service sets these logging defaults:**"
+                  echo '```nix'
+                  echo "$logging_defaults" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r 'to_entries[] | "  \(.key) = \(.value);"'
+                  echo '```'
+              fi
+              echo
+          fi
+
+          # Proxy Feature
+          if [[ "$has_proxy" == "true" ]]; then
+              echo "##### 🔀 Proxy Integration"
+              echo
+              echo "Available proxy options:"
+              echo
+              echo '```nix'
+              echo "homelab.services.$service = {"
+              echo "  # ... core options above ..."
+              echo
+
+              echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.proxy.options[] | @base64' | while IFS= read -r option_b64; do
+                  option=$(echo "$option_b64" | base64 -d)
+
+                  name=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.name')
+                  type=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.type')
+                  default_val=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.default')
+                  description=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.description')
+                  read_only=$(echo "$option" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.readOnly')
+
+                  if [[ "$read_only" == "true" ]]; then
+                      continue
+                  fi
+
+                  clean_description=$(echo "$description" | sed 's/"/\\"/g' | tr -d $'\n\r')
+
+                  if [[ "$default_val" == "null" ]]; then
+                      echo "  # $name = <$type>;  # $clean_description"
+                  else
+                      echo "  $name = $default_val;  # $clean_description"
+                  fi
+              done
+
+              echo "};"
+              echo '```'
+
+              # Show service-specific proxy defaults
+              proxy_defaults=$(echo "$service_data" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r '.features.proxy.defaults')
+              if [[ "$proxy_defaults" != "{}" && "$proxy_defaults" != "null" ]]; then
+                  echo
+                  echo "**$service sets these proxy defaults:**"
+                  echo '```nix'
+                  echo "$proxy_defaults" | ${jq}/bin/jq -r 'to_entries[] | "  \(.key) = \(.value);"'
+                  echo '```'
+              fi
+              echo
+          fi
       fi
 
       echo "---"
       echo
   done
 
-  echo "## Integration Summary"
+  echo "## Feature Reference"
   echo
-  echo "### Available Integration Types"
+  echo "### Integration Features"
   echo
-  echo "| Integration | Purpose | Default Behavior | Configuration |"
-  echo "|-------------|---------|------------------|---------------|"
-  echo "| **📊 Monitoring** | Prometheus metrics + health checks | Service-dependent | \`monitoring.enable = true\` |"
-  echo "| **📝 Logging** | Centralized log collection | Service-dependent | \`logging.enable = true\` |"
-  echo "| **🔀 Proxy** | Reverse proxy with SSL + auth | Service-dependent | \`proxy.enable = true\` |"
+  echo "Homelab services can integrate with three main features:"
   echo
-  echo "### Integration Benefits"
+  echo "- **📊 Monitoring**: Prometheus metrics and health checks"
+  echo "- **📝 Logging**: Centralized log collection with Promtail/Loki"
+  echo "- **🔀 Proxy**: Reverse proxy with SSL and authentication"
   echo
-  echo "- **🔄 Automatic Discovery:** Enabled integrations are automatically discovered by fleet-wide services"
-  echo "- **📊 Unified Monitoring:** All metrics and health checks appear in Prometheus/Grafana"
-  echo "- **📝 Centralized Logging:** All logs are collected and indexed in Loki"
-  echo "- **🌐 Consistent Access:** All services get consistent subdomain access with SSL"
-  echo "- **🎯 Smart Defaults:** Each service comes with sensible default configurations"
+  echo "Each service can import these features and set service-specific defaults."
   echo
   echo "---"
   echo
-  echo "*This service catalog is generated from actual service configurations across your homelab fleet.*"
+  echo "*This documentation is generated from actual NixOS module evaluations.*"
 ''

From e276c47686b115abf3bdf366f4bcc50713dff619 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: plasmagoat <david.mikael@proton.me>
Date: Wed, 30 Jul 2025 00:22:53 +0200
Subject: [PATCH 2/2] err

---
 pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix | 138 ------------------------
 1 file changed, 138 deletions(-)
 delete mode 100644 pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix

diff --git a/pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix b/pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix
deleted file mode 100644
index dba33df..0000000
--- a/pkgs/homelab-docs/service-evaluator.nix
+++ /dev/null
@@ -1,138 +0,0 @@
-# service-evaluator.nix - Pure Nix evaluation logic for service documentation
-{
-  nodes,
-  pkgs,
-  lib,
-  ...
-}: let
-  # Helper to recursively extract option information
-  extractOptions = path: options: let
-    pathStr = lib.concatStringsSep "." path;
-  in
-    lib.flatten (lib.mapAttrsToList (
-        name: value: let
-          currentPath = path ++ [name];
-          currentPathStr = lib.concatStringsSep "." currentPath;
-        in
-          if (value._type or null) == "option"
-          then
-            # This is an actual NixOS option
-            [
-              {
-                name = currentPathStr;
-                type = value.type.description or (builtins.typeOf (value.default or null));
-                default = value.default or null;
-                defaultText =
-                  if value ? defaultText
-                  then value.defaultText.text or null
-                  else null;
-                description = value.description or "No description available";
-                example = value.example or null;
-                readOnly = value.readOnly or false;
-              }
-            ]
-          else if lib.isAttrs value && !(lib.hasAttr "_type" value)
-          then
-            # This is a nested attribute set, recurse
-            extractOptions currentPath value
-          else
-            # Skip other types
-            []
-      )
-      options);
-
-  # Get service options from the first node (they should be the same across nodes)
-  firstNode = lib.head (lib.attrValues nodes);
-  homelabServices = firstNode.options.homelab.services or {};
-
-  # Extract all services and their options
-  serviceDefinitions =
-    lib.mapAttrs (serviceName: serviceOptions: {
-      inherit serviceName;
-      options = extractOptions [] serviceOptions;
-      features = let
-        optionNames = map (opt: opt.name) (extractOptions [] serviceOptions);
-      in {
-        hasMonitoring = lib.any (name: lib.hasPrefix "monitoring" name) optionNames;
-        hasLogging = lib.any (name: lib.hasPrefix "logging" name) optionNames;
-        hasProxy = lib.any (name: lib.hasPrefix "proxy" name) optionNames;
-      };
-    })
-    homelabServices;
-
-  # Also get all services that exist in actual configurations (for deployment info)
-  allConfiguredServices = lib.unique (lib.flatten (lib.mapAttrsToList (
-      nodeName: node:
-        if (node.config.homelab.enable or false)
-        then lib.attrNames (node.config.homelab.services or {})
-        else []
-    )
-    nodes));
-
-  # For each service, get deployment info
-  serviceDeployments = lib.listToAttrs (map (serviceName: {
-      name = serviceName;
-      value =
-        lib.foldl (
-          acc: nodeName: let
-            node = nodes.${nodeName};
-            serviceConfig = node.config.homelab.services.${serviceName} or null;
-            isEnabled =
-              if serviceConfig != null
-              then serviceConfig.enable or false
-              else false;
-          in
-            if serviceConfig != null
-            then
-              acc
-              // {
-                totalNodes = acc.totalNodes + 1;
-                enabledNodes =
-                  acc.enabledNodes
-                  + (
-                    if isEnabled
-                    then 1
-                    else 0
-                  );
-                nodeNames = acc.nodeNames ++ [nodeName];
-                enabledNodeNames =
-                  acc.enabledNodeNames
-                  ++ (
-                    if isEnabled
-                    then [nodeName]
-                    else []
-                  );
-              }
-            else acc
-        ) {
-          totalNodes = 0;
-          enabledNodes = 0;
-          nodeNames = [];
-          enabledNodeNames = [];
-        } (lib.attrNames nodes);
-    })
-    allConfiguredServices);
-
-  # Combine service definitions with deployment info
-  servicesWithDeployment =
-    lib.mapAttrs (
-      serviceName: serviceData:
-        serviceData
-        // {
-          deployment =
-            serviceDeployments.${
-              serviceName
-            } or {
-              totalNodes = 0;
-              enabledNodes = 0;
-              nodeNames = [];
-              enabledNodeNames = [];
-            };
-        }
-    )
-    serviceDefinitions;
-in {
-  services = servicesWithDeployment;
-  totalServices = lib.length (lib.attrNames servicesWithDeployment);
-  allConfiguredServices = allConfiguredServices;
-}